Pali / English side-by-side
Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammāsambuddhassa
3.10.8.4 Paṭṭhānapāli – Cittavīthi, Part Four
The Process of Cognition
Kiccasaṅgahe kiccāni nāma
paṭisandhibhavaṅgāvajjanadassanasavanaghāyanasāyanaphusanasampaṭicchanasantīraṇavoṭṭhapanajavanatadārammaṇacutivasena
cuddasavidhāni bhavanti.
In the compendium of functions there are fourteen kinds: rebirth-linking, life-continuum, adverting, seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, touching, receiving, investigating, determining, javana, registration and departure.
Pali term | Word formation (literal) | English terminology | Thought-moments | Definition | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
kicca |
karoti (ger.) lit: that which should be done, duty, obligation |
function |
|
In the section on miscellaneous, it is explained that there are fourteen different functions that certain cittāni can perform. Some can take on separate functions under different circumstances. These functions make cognition possible that takes place either within the process or constitutes the process of cognition (cittavīthi). If it takes place outside of it, it is called process-freed (vīthimutta).
|
1 |
paṭisandhi |
paṭi + sandhi: (pref.) towards, up to + union, joint, connection: reunion, relinking, conception |
rebirth-linking |
|
It is a function that occurs at conception and ‘links’ the previous existence to the new, present one. It ‘contains’ the mood or character of the last citta of the previous existence and implements this mood into the new life stream of the bhavaṅga. It is said that here the latent ‘character’ of the new individual gets determined which flows throughout that existence.1 |
2 |
bhavaṅga |
bhava + aṅga: becoming + limb, existence + constituent: life-continuum |
life-continuum
|
1 |
It is a term that occurs only in the later Pāli texts. It describes the indispensable condition of existence, hence the translation of ‘life-continuum’ seems appropriate. It preserves the individual mood or character that has been ‘implanted’ through the paṭisandhicitta from the first moment of existence to the last. The bhavaṅgacitta thus preserves the continuity of the character and mood that it has received from the paṭisandhicitta. In the process of cognition the bhavaṅga silently maintains its stream, vibrates (bhavaṅgacalana) and stops (bhavaṅga-upaccheda) whenever an object comes into the sphere of any of the six sense-doors and resumes its flow once the object is determined.
|
3 |
āvajjana |
turning to, adverting the mind apprehending, paying attention |
adverting |
1 |
Āvajjana refers to an alertness that ‘something has occurred in the range of any of the sense-doors. It is called pañcadvārāvajjana in case it is a material object; it gets labelled manodvārāvajjana in the case of a mental object.
|
4 |
dassana-savana-ghāyana-sāyana-phusana |
seeing- hearing- smelling- tasting- touching |
seeing- hearing- smelling- tasting- touching |
|
These refer to the functions of the five sense-door-consciousnesses (pañcadvārāviññāṇna) which in this context simply turn to the impression that has arrived at the range of the respective sense door. These work through the cakkhuviññāṇa, sotaviññāṇa, ghānaviññāṇa, jivhāviññāṇa, kāyaviññāṇa.
|
5 |
sampaṭicchana |
acceptance, agreement |
receiving |
1 |
This is the ahetukacitta ‘upekkhāsahagata sampaṭicchanacitta’2 that marks or receives without noting any details.
|
6 |
santīraṇa |
investigation, judging a sense-impression
|
investigating |
1 |
This is the ahetukacitta ‘upekkhāsahagata santīraṇacitta’ that investigates and analyses details of the objects so far only marked or received. The object ‘invites’ inquisitiveness to determine its nature.
|
7 |
voṭṭhapana |
establishing, synthesis, determination |
determining |
1 |
Here the nature of the object is determined and discriminated.
|
8 |
javana |
alacrity, running, swift understanding |
javana |
7 |
The seven thought-moments of this process are ‘going quickly’ and remain untranslated as javana.
|
9 |
tadārammaṇa |
tad + ārammaṇa: (that + object), registration, retention |
registering, registration |
2 |
All ‘technical’ details like form, colour, taste, smell etc. are registered, the object is cognised. After the two thought-moments of the tadārammaṇa, the stream of consciousness again lapses into the bhavaṅga. It is also called tadālambana. |
10 |
cuti |
departure, passing away, death, vanishing, shifting out of existence |
death |
|
Cuti is the process-freed citta that is the final consciousness of this existence, the consciousness of departure. It belongs to the three ‘members’ of the vīthimutta-process. It is the bhavaṅga that performs the function of cuti; the ‘mood’ of it remains the same as that of the life-continuum but occurs for a last time. The bhavaṅga of the next existence is terminated by the next paṭisandhicitta and will have a different ‘mood’. |
1. Ven. Nāgasena replies to King Milinda that the one reborn is not the same, nor another. It is a chain of phenomena that are linked together, where one phenomenon arises and another vanishes, one after the other, without interruption, yet all are linked together. Thus one remains neither the same nor is one another. See also the footnote in the Introduction.
2. ahetukacittāni is the term for the eighteen states of minds that have no roots but execute mere functional tasks. Sampaṭicchanacitta, as well as the santīraṇacitta mark wholesome as well as unwholesome objects in the same way as the pañcadvārāviññāṇna. See 3.10.8.2 Paṭṭhānapāli – Citta, Part Two – States of Consciousness - Catuvīsati Sahetukakāmāvacarakusalavipākakiriyacittāni
Vocabulary
- cuddasavidhāni - [cuddasa + vidhāni] fourteen + kinds, fold, consisting of
- upaccheda - [upaccheda (upa + chid)] stoppage, interruption, breaking off
- calana - trembling, shaking, moving, vibrating
- vasena - [vasa (instr.)] power, control: on account of, because